CDEs and Accountability

CDEs and Accountability

An organization seeking awards under the New Markets Tax Credits (“NMTC”) Program must be certified as a community development entity (“CDE”) by the Community Development Financial Institutions Fund (“CDFI Fund”). One of the requirements for an organization to qualify as a CDE is that the organization must maintain accountability to its targeted low-income communities (“LIC”).

The NMTC Program is jointly administered by the CDFI Fund and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). Any program investments must comply with regulations contained in § 45D of the Internal Revenue Code. The contents of an Allocation Application are consistent with the Internal Revenue Code § 45D and the NMTC Program Income Tax Regulations. I.R.C. §45D(c)(1)(B) provides guidance on the accountability rules for a qualified CDE. If a CDE serves many geographic areas, the CDE must demonstrate accountability to each of these service areas.

Accountability to residents of LICs is maintained through the CDE’s representation on the governing board of the entity or on any advisory board of the entity. If a CDE uses an advisory board to meet the accountability requirement, the CDE must have the ability to demonstrate that the advisory board’s viewpoints receive sufficient consideration by any governing board. A minimum of 20 percent of the members of an advisory board must be representative of the LIC served by the CDE.

Only if the board member resides in a LIC within the entity’s designated service area or otherwise represents the interest of residents of the LIC will the member be considered representative of the LIC. The CDFI Fund encourages the appointment of low-income persons from the LIC to an advisory board.

CDEs with a national, multi-state, or statewide service area must show that at least 20 percent of the advisory board is representative of a cross-section of the LIC(s) within the area(s) that it serves. The CDFI Fund recommends that CDEs with a large geographic service area appoint at least one person to the advisory board accountable to LICs throughout this extensive service area.

To satisfy the goals and purposes of the NMTC Program and reasonably ensure that it meets all accountability test regulations, an entity should create formal written policies and procedures. It is also recommended that CDEs issue an annual compliance report which certifies accountability and make a statement that the CDE has maintained governing or advisory board status.

Also, at least once annually, a CDE should monitor and maintain the status of each board member by verifying that information submitted with the CDE’s Certification Application remains true and correct. Savage & Associates can help your CDE establish these necessary and crucial protocols to meet the accountability test requirements. Call us today!

Let’s Work Together to Develop our Communities

If you want to learn more about NMTCs, contact Savage & Associates at 215.880.9441 in Philadelphia, or 202.817.3941 in Washington D.C. to arrange a consultation. Dionne Savage can assist you to gain access to the benefits provided by the New Markets Tax Credits, Low-Income Housing Tax Credits, C-PACE, Historic Tax Credits, and other vital economic development tools that benefit local communities throughout the United States. Visit our website at Savage & Associates 24 hours a day, seven days a week for more information.

How a Non-Profit Takes Advantage of NMTCs

How a Non-Profit Takes Advantage of NMTCs

The New Markets Tax Credits Program (“NMTC Program”) is an advantageous tool for nonprofit organizations. The NMTC Program provides benefits to nonprofits consistent with their exempt function. The NMTC may provide subsidy or gap financing to tax-exempt organizations that engage in real estate development, business operations, or charitable activities in qualified census tracts.

Nonprofit and other charitable organizations have several options for participating in the NMTC Program. The first option is the tax-exempt entity that acts as a QALICB that is the entity that participates in the development, business, or charitable operations that occur in the low-income community (“LIC”). Another option is as a for-profit organization that is a subsidiary of a nonprofit organization. A tax-exempt organization like a charity often will create a supporting organization under § 509(a)(3) to participate in the NMTC transaction.

A third option is a tax-exempt organization that acts as a leverage lender in an NMTC transaction. The leverage lender provides debt financing that, when combined with an investors’ equity financing, allows investors to increase the amount of tax credits it receives in exchange for the equity investment. As a leveraged lender, the nonprofit must set up a procedure that allows it to assume control if problems develop at the project/QALICB level and funds are redirected to the CDE.

A CDE that is awarded an NMTC allocation must ensure that it complies with the NMTC program at all times. It must strictly adhere to the allocation agreement it enters into with the CDFI Fund. However, as a leverage lender, the nonprofit has little control over the operations of the community development entity (“CDE”) or qualified active low-income community business (“QALICB”) during the seven years that the investor receives benefits from the tax credits.

A charitable organization acting as the leverage lender must also consider other issues in this role. First, the tax-exempt organization must ensure that the funds invested in the CDE are applied consistently with the leverage lender’s charitable purpose and community benefit. One way to address this issue is by obtaining an opinion of counsel delivered at the transaction’s initial closing. The opinion must conform to § 170(c) and conclude that the funds invested in the CDE will be used consistently with the nonprofit’s charitable purpose.

Examples of QALICBs

  • *An operating business such as a grocer, manufacturer, or retailer located in a LIC.
  • *A business that develops or rehabilitates retail, commercial, industrial, and mixed‐use real estate projects in a LIC.
  • *A business that develops or rehabilitates community facilities, such as healthcare facilities or schools, in a LIC.
  • *A business that develops or rehabilitates marketed housing units located in a LIC.

Generally, a QALICB includes any corporation, including a nonprofit corporation, partnership, or limited liability company (“LLC”) that meets the following requirements for any tax year:

(1) 50 percent or more of the organization’s total gross income originates from the activities of a qualified business within any LIC,

(2) at least 40 percent of the organization’s tangible property, whether owned or leased, is used in a LIC,

(3) at least 40 percent of the services performed by the organization’s employees are performed in a LIC, and

(4) less than 5 percent of the average of the aggregate unadjusted bases of the property of the organization is attributable to either nonqualified financial property or collectibles, other than collectibles held primarily for sale to customers in the ordinary course of the business.

Let’s Work Together to Develop our Communities

If you want to learn more about NMTCs, contact Savage & Associates at 215.880.9441 in Philadelphia, or 202.817.3941 in Washington D.C. to arrange a consultation. Dionne Savage can assist you to gain access to the benefits provided by the New Markets Tax Credits, Low-Income Housing Tax Credits, C-PACE, Historic Tax Credits, and other vital economic development tools that benefit local communities throughout the United States. Visit our website at Savage & Associates 24 hours a day, seven days a week for more information.

NMTC Case Study: Pittsburgh Urban Initiatives, LLC

NMTC Case Study: Pittsburgh Urban Initiatives, LLC

The Urban Redevelopment Authority of Pittsburgh (URA) announced last September that the Community Development Financial Institutions Fund (CDFI Fund) had awarded $50 million in New Markets Tax Credits (NMTC) to Pittsburgh Urban Initiatives (PUI). PUI is a Community Development Entity (CDE) affiliated with and sponsored by the URA, and one of only 100 entities in the nation to receive funding and one of only 16 CDEs serving local markets. 

The CDFI Fund awarded allocations to 100 Community Development Entities, representing 48% of the total pool of applicants. The individual allocation amounts ranged from $15 million to $65 million and the total amount allocated was almost $5 billion. Of this, 78% ($3.8 billion) of these investment proceeds will likely be used to support financing and investment in businesses operating in low-income communities. The remaining 22% ($1.1 billion) of these NMTC investment proceeds will likely be used to finance and support real estate projects in these same low-income communities.

PUI’s NMTC funding is overseen by the PUI Governing Board and Advisory Board, consisting of the URA executive director and URA board chairman, staff, foundations, and community development professionals who represent low-income communities throughout Pittsburgh. The URA is the City of Pittsburgh’s agency that works toward achieving the City’s economic development goals.

The URA website describes PUI’s mission as follows “to strategically invest in office, retail, mixed-use, and community facility developments designed to rehabilitate abandoned and blighted sites in the City of Pittsburgh. With continued success raising NMTC allocation available to Pittsburgh, PUI has helped drive increased investment activity in Pittsburgh’s neighborhoods to close deals that “but for” the NMTC would not be possible.”

PUI supports the community and economic development objectives of the Urban Redevelopment Authority of Pittsburgh. NMTC allocation awards to PUI have provided more than 3,792 permanent jobs, 4,443 residential units, and 3,066 construction jobs. In addition, NMTC funding of PUI projects has created over half a billion dollars in total project costs.

Since February 2011, including the current amount of $50 million, PUI has received seven awards for a total of $238 million in NMTC allocations. These awards have helped finance several Pittsburgh development projects, including East End Cooperative Ministry’s Community House, the Energy Innovation Center, Wood Street Commons, scattered site affordable housing in Garfield and East Liberty, 7800 Susquehanna Street, Point Park University’s Pittsburgh Playhouse, and City of Asylum.

“This NMTC allocation will allow the URA to continue investing in projects that create community benefit through jobs, improved access to commercial services such as fresh food, and much needed affordable for-sale housing,” said URA Executive Director Greg Flisram.

Senator Bob Casey (D-PA) also extended his compliments to PUI. “I’d like to extend my congratulations to Pittsburgh Urban Initiatives for securing $50 million in New Markets Tax Credits. This award will spur economic growth, job creation, and neighborhood revitalization, and I look forward to seeing the benefits that Southwestern Pennsylvanian communities will see as a result of this investment.” 

As a CDE, PUI’s hard work has had a substantial effect on low-income neighborhoods by facilitating New Markets Tax Credit (NMTC) investments for projects in Pittsburgh.

It is never too early to start preparing for the next round of NMTC allocations. Savage & Associates can help you every step of the way.. Call us today!

Let’s Work Together to Develop our Communities [update – review my edits and replace below]

If you want to learn more about NMTCs, contact Savage & Associates at 215.880.9441 in Philadelphia, or 202.817.3941 in Washington D.C. to arrange a consultation. Dionne Savage can assist you to evaluate the benefits provided by the New Market Tax Credits, Low-Income Housing Tax Credits, C-PACE, Historic Tax Credits programs, and other vital economic development tools that benefit low-income communities throughout the United States. Visit our website at Savage & Associates 24 hours a day, seven days a week for more information.

About The New Markets Tax Credits Extension Act of 2021

About The New Markets Tax Credits Extension Act of 2021

Legislation to make the New Markets Tax Credit (NMTC) Program permanent is on the floor of both houses of Congress as S. 456 and H.R. 1321, better known as the New Markets Tax Credits Extension Act of 2021 (the “Act”). The New Markets Tax Credit program is scheduled to terminate in 2025 but amendments made by the Act, introduced on February 25, 2021, would extend it permanently and apply to all taxable years beginning after December 31, 2020.

Some quick facts about the NMTC program:

  • *Through 2020, NMTC allocations totaling $60 billion have provided almost $110 billion in total project financing to over 7,000 projects.
  • *In 2020, over 80 percent of NMTC projects were in communities experiencing severe economic distress.
  • *In 2020, 24 percent of NMTC investments were in rural areas.
  • *Through 2015, the NMTC created 1 million jobs costing the federal govt. less than $20,000 per job.

The New Markets Tax Credits Extension Act of 2021 expands recent Congressional legislation that extended the NMTC through 2025. In 2019, Congress increased the amount of credits available by 44 percent to $5 billion. The Act increases the efficiency of the NMTC program and delivers more capital to low-income communities (LICs). In sum, the Act:

  • *Provides an indefinite extension of the NMTC;
  • *Indexes future allocation levels to inflation; and
  • *Attracts new investors by exempting the NMTC from the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMY).

The need to provide relief because of the COVID-19 pandemic helped steer congressional efforts to extend the NMTC program. “The COVID-19 pandemic has laid bare the historic disinvestments in our rural and underserved communities. Now more than ever, it is critically important that our communities have permanent access to the New Market Tax Credit as a tool to facilitate investments in local businesses and community development projects as we recover from our economic crisis,” said Rep. Terri Sewell in a press release. “The NMTC remains crucial to the creation of job growth and opportunity in Alabama’s 7th Congressional District, and I’m proud to introduce this bipartisan bill to ensure our most underserved communities are not left behind.”

The annual impact of the New Markets Tax Credits equates to $25 billion and includes an estimated 690 new manufacturing expansions and industrial projects; 275 mixed-use projects combining housing, commercial, and social services; 255 new or improved health clinics, hospitals, and medical offices; and 775 investments in daycare centers, Boys and Girls Clubs, and other community facilities. It is also expected to create an estimated 590,000 jobs.

“Following devastating impacts from COVID-19, the New Markets Tax Credit is absolutely vital for many of America’s urban neighborhoods and rural communities and will provide billions of dollars for high-impact, community revitalization projects,” said Bob Rapoza, spokesperson for the NMTC Coalition. “Over the years, the credit has been instrumental in financing plant and equipment for small manufacturing businesses and patient flexible capital to other small businesses, hospitals, healthcare centers, homeless shelters, and other transformative projects that improve communities, create jobs and economic opportunity. We appreciate the leadership of several members of Congress in championing this effort for communities across the U.S., including Reps. Terri Sewell (D-AL) and Tom Reed (R-NY)and  Sens. Ben Cardin (D-MD) and Roy Blunt (R-MO).”

In an open letter to the Senate Finance and Ways & Means Committees in May, the American Bankers Association (ABA) expressed its support for the legislation. An independent compliance review found that NMTC program participants significantly lower the cost of capital for borrowers in low-income communities and exceed statutory and regulatory requirements for the targeting of economic distress.

Let’s Work Together to Develop our Communities

If you want to learn more about NMTCs, contact Savage & Associates at 215.880.9441 in Philadelphia, or 202.817.3941 in Washington D.C. to arrange a consultation. Dionne Savage can assist you to gain access to the benefits provided by the New Markets Tax Credits, Low-Income Housing Tax Credits, C-PACE, Historic Tax Credits, and other vital economic development tools that benefit local communities throughout the United States. Visit our website at Savage & Associates 24 hours a day, seven days a week for more information.

Community Outcomes: An Important Part Of A Qualified NMTC Application

Community Outcomes: An Important Part Of A Qualified NMTC Application

The review of an NMTC application is an arduous, painstakingly meticulous process. Two sections of the application are not only evaluated but scored, by reviewers. The sections that are both reviewed and scored include the “Business Strategy” and “Community Outcomes” sections of each application. In a past blog, we discussed the “Business Strategy” section and how to complete it so that it and your NMTC Application is highly qualified to receive an NMTC award.

Community Outcomes has always been a significant section of the application since the inception of the program. Simply, it addresses the impact of the project on the community. Older applications included a section entitled “Community Impact.” This section requires more diligence to articulate what projects will be in the CDE’s pipeline.

In “Community Outcomes,” the CDFI Fund first looks to see that the applicant’s methods are clear and sound. In turn, the Fund looks at the metrics that support these methods. Metrics from a third party are more valuable than any that are derived from the applicant’s track record. Showing more than one level of impact is valuable. Some outcomes may not always be obvious to a CDE and its partners.

It’s important for CDEs to understand their projected outcomes and to articulate their track records for achieving similar effect projects. How a CDE’s track record compares with its projected outcomes is of critical importance. Some secondary impacts of the project may be overlooked. Unfortunately, any outcome that is difficult to quantify is often overlooked in this situation.

While job and real estate production tend to be among the most commonly measured outputs and outcomes of community and economic development programs, the following outcomes are also very relevant: (1) creation of amenities, services, and facilities; (2) support for small businesses and organizations; and (3) enhancement of local tax bases.

On a project-by-project basis, consideration is given to which, if any, of the following potential outputs or outcomes are associated with each early-year project: increased employment; developed real estate; improved environment; reduced neighborhood distress; increased community amenities, services, or facilities; new or expanded businesses; attraction of new investors; or provision of advantageous financing.

To receive a score in the highest range in each of the two scored sections for the CY 2020 application and receive the maximum Priority Points, an Applicant generally needed to demonstrate the following specific characteristics related to Community Outcomes:

1. Targeting Areas of Higher Distress (Question 24).

The Applicant must indicate that it will commit to providing at least 75% of its Qualified Low-Income Community Investments (QLICIs) in specified areas of severe distress and/or areas characterized by multiple indicators of distress. The Applicant also must show that its strategy for locating and prioritizing QLICIs in highly distressed communities is highly likely to be effective.

2. Community Development Outcomes (Question 25).

For each outcome selected in Question 25, the Applicant must show that its planned investments are likely to result in significant community outcomes that would clearly benefit Low-Income Persons and/or residents of Low-Income Communities (LICs). All the Applicant’s projected community outcomes must be quantified and supported by sound and clearly explained methods. The Applicant must demonstrate that it validated the reasonableness of the quantified projections with metrics obtained from or informed by third-party source(s), where required based on the outcomes selected. In addition, the Applicant must demonstrate a strong track record of achieving outcomes similar in type and quantity to the projected outcomes.

3. Tracking Community Outcomes (Question 25b).

The Applicant must describe a thorough track record and robust methodology for tracking all projected community outcomes.

4. Community Accountability and Involvement (Question 26).

The Applicant must demonstrate that proposed investments are supported by and beneficial to the communities it serves by outlining an effective process, including a significant role for LIC representatives on its Advisory and/or Governing Board, to ensure planned investments align with LIC priorities. The Applicant also must show an extensive track record of project-specific community engagement in past investment decisions and how its proposed investments will contribute to broader (local, regional, or state-wide) community or economic development strategies or plans.

5. Other Community Benefits (Question 27).

The Applicant must demonstrate a high likelihood that its proposed investments will result in additional non-NMTC related private investment in LICs beyond the initial NMTC investment, as supported by specific track record examples of financing catalytic projects that have spurred additional private investment.

Let’s Work Together to Develop our Communities

If you want to learn more about NMTCs, contact Savage & Associates at 215.880.9441 in Philadelphia, or 202.817.3941 in Washington D.C. to arrange a consultation. Dionne Savage can assist you to gain access to the benefits provided by the New Markets Tax Credits, Low-Income Housing Tax Credits, C-PACE, Historic Tax Credits, and other vital economic development tools that benefit local communities throughout the United States. Visit our website at Savage & Associates 24 hours a day, seven days a week for more information.

The General Characteristics Of A Highly Ranked NMTC Application – Part Two

The General Characteristics Of A Highly Ranked NMTC Application – Part Two

Part One of this blog discussed the New Markets Tax Credits (NMTC) Application Process. There are two phases to the NMTC Application process. Unfortunately, not all applications make it to the second phase. Our goal is to provide you with helpful tips to improve your NMTC application. An application must demonstrate a business strategy possessing certain characteristics when it is evaluated in Phase One to ensure that it receives a high enough score to qualify for continued evaluation in Phase Two. Today, we will discuss the characteristics that may enhance your NMTC application’s business strategy and hopefully merit an NMTC allocation.

There were 208 Allocation Applications made by various Community Development Entities (CDEs) throughout the country. The Community Development Financial Institutions Fund (CDFI Fund) received requests for $15.1 billion in NMTC allocations. One hundred CDEs, or 48.1% of the applicant pool, received allocation awards totaling $5 billion, which constituted approximately 33.1% of the total amount requested by applicants.

As would be expected, the financial health of the Applicant is of paramount importance. Factors such as the fee structure and the overall financial stability of the Applicant’s business entity are also characteristics of a potentially highly qualified application.

A good application will indicate:

  1.  The Applicant possesses a track record of raising Qualified Equity Investments (QEIs).
  2.  The Applicant’s past NMTC activities with prior Allocation Applications.
  3. The Applicant’s proposed commitments to provide Qualified Low-Income Community Investments (QLICIs) in Non-Metropolitan Counties.
  4. The Applicant’s  propensity to engage in innovative investments.

Applications are scored on a point system. An NMTC application will receive up to five additional points for demonstrating consistent service to disadvantaged businesses or communities. An application will also receive up to five additional points for committing to invest substantially all proceeds from QEIs. Applications that fail to achieve certain minimum scores in the Business Strategy section and Community Outcomes section of the application will receive no further consideration and will be deemed not to be highly qualified NMTC applications.

Because the Panel reviews information related to prior allocations in Phase Two, it is important to be prepared to explain any discrepancies that may cause questions or unfavorable conclusions related to former awards. It is also important to be prepared to provide any supplemental information requested by the CDFI Fund during the Phase One review process.

A highly ranked application will demonstrate that the Applicant has a high capacity to deploy and monitor NMTC investments. It will show a history of the Applicant’s business providing direct loans or equity investments. An exemplary application will exhibit the important relationships and consequential benefits for a Qualified Active Low-Income Community Business (QALICB). It will clearly show a healthy distribution of benefits among the investor, CDEs, and QALICBs.

A qualified application will prove that clear and meaningful community outcomes are likely to occur and benefit low-income persons or residents of low-income communities. And, that the Applicant’s investment decisions meet the needs of the communities they support and the economic development priorities of low-income communities they serve.

Further, a successful Applicant will unequivocally demonstrate that its products will be significantly more flexible than market standards. For each product, the Applicant will clearly describe the circumstances under which and how frequently the best rates and terms would be available and provide examples and comparisons to what is typically offered by the Applicant and offered by other financial institutions or investors in the Applicant’s service area. The Applicant will provide an example of how each proposed product will be used to finance a proposed  NMTC investment.

For most Applicants, the application will indicate debt with interest rates of at least 50% below-market; or debt that otherwise satisfies the relevant requirements. Applicants investing in other CDEs will demonstrate a high likelihood that they will pass favorable rates and terms along to the borrowers.

The Applicant should demonstrate that it possesses the ability to begin making NMTC investments promptly. A highly qualified application will demonstrate the Applicant’s ability to deploy QLICIs commensurate with the allocation request.

If the application proposes to fund a single or small number of projects, the Applicant must demonstrate a high likelihood that its proposed projects are feasible based on the ability to secure financing, that they will close as planned, that the risks to timely closing are limited, and clearly identified. The application should present this information in tandem with a superior risk mitigation plan.

Finally, related to demonstrating an effective business strategy, a highly qualified application will demonstrate, during each of the past five years, an excellent track record of directly providing products and services similar to those it would provide with the QEI proceeds. An application with a relatively limited record of providing QLICI-type activities could also achieve a high score if it has a very strong five-year or longer track record of non-QLICI like investments that are distinctly aligned with its current business strategy.

Let’s Work Together to Develop our Communities If you want to learn more about NMTCs, contact Savage & Associates at 215.880.9441 in Philadelphia, or 202.817.3941 in Washington D.C. to arrange a consultation. Dionne Savage can assist you to evaluate the benefits provided by the New Market Tax Credits, Low-Income Housing Tax Credits, C-PACE, Historic Tax Credits programs, and other vital economic development tools that benefit low-income communities throughout the United States. Visit our website at Savage & Associates 24 hours a day, seven days a week for more information.